The current system and what was changedFor those who are unfamiliar with the karma/flagging system, it works in the following ways:
- Player A decides to flag up and hit Player B for whatever reason.
- Player A loses 10k karma for hitting the person.
- If Player A kills Player B they will lose an additional 60k karma.
- If Player B fights back and kills Player A they lose nothing.
- You can have a maximum of 300k karma and minimum of -1,000,000 karma.
- If you go into negative karma, you have a chance of losing gems when you die in PvP, and can also lose experience or your items can degrade if you die in PvE. In the desert, these punishments are not as harsh but you can be sent to jail if you die in PvP. Everyone is free to kill you whilst you are in negative karma, you are permanently flagged up and will lose more karma if you defend yourself.
- You can slowly get karma back by killing monsters.
Why this caused such an outrageThe issues are not with the amount of karma you lose and this is not why people should be upset. The issue itself is caused by the current system and this has been a problem in the game for a very long time. There is literally no “risk vs reward”, no benefits to PK and only severe punishments, and this is where “Karma Bombing” becomes acceptable.
Reverting the changes in the latest patch does not fix this and will only delay it. Karma Bombing is still possible due to broken mechanics.
For example: You have been grinding at a spot for over an hour uninterrupted. Another player shows up a begins to follow you around and try to out farm you to push you out of the spot. You flag up and kill the player (-120k karma), then carry on with your rotation. The player has lost nothing and it only takes them around 30 seconds to resurrect and come back. They begin following you again and even if they aren’t out farming you and they are weaker, they know all they have to do is keep annoying you and you’ll be the one forced to leave. The player is not in a guild, or may be in a guild that you cannot war against, so you are forced into 5 options.
Option 1: Keep killing them until they get bored. This will cause you to go into negative karma and the punishments are simply too severe to make this a viable option, especially since the griefer loses nothing and can then freely attack and harass you when you are in negative karma.
Option 2: Attempt to party with the player. Unfortunately, whilst this option makes the most sense in an MMO, it is the mechanics themselves which discourage it. There isn’t enough benefit to grinding in a party and unless all members pull their weight, the strongest player is the one missing out. It is just not efficient enough due to the way the game is set up.
Option 3: Ignore them and attempt to out farm them. This option is not ideal because you will be the one missing out. Some classes, such as Valkyrie, also farm slower and it can be very hard to out farm another player even if they are a lot stronger.
Option 4: Change channel. This is the option that most players will take. You let the griefer win and they get the rotation despite you being stronger and “earning” it. You come away with less karma and have to risk changing into a populated channel, perhaps even becoming the griefer on that one.
Option 5: Fight griefing with more griefing. I feel embarrassed and ashamed that this is even an option, but due to broken mechanics it makes more sense for you to actually flag up and just harass the player, perhaps even letting them die to monsters and losing 1%. This is the only effective way to keep the spot, despite being stronger.
As you can see, the current karma/flagging system not only makes griefing acceptable, but actually encourages it. This is what needs to change!
It doesn’t matter if you are stronger, because it is the stronger person who loses out no matter what. Perhaps the weaker guilds should own the castles in conquest wars too?
Why this change does NOT protect new players or PvE players
Although this change means we can kill less people before going negative, it will not actually protect the new players or those who want to simply PvE. If someone wants to go around griefing them, then they will. Karma loss will not make any difference. There are already harsh punishments in place to prevent griefing and I can honestly say I’ve never been PK’d without some sort of reason.
In fact, the changes have caused a greater divide between the community, with many veterans blaming “steam players” for the sudden timing of the karma change. New players are not the ones to blame here!
What the Karma system used to be and what we were promised
Before the game launched in EU/NA, the karma system was under fire and a large portion of the community voiced their issues with the karma system we still have today. In one of the early PM Diary’s the karma system was discussed and a Bounty Hunter system was shown to players so that we could give feedback. The proposed system seemed to address most of the concerns, but we never heard any more about it. It was “half” implemented with the Valencia expansion, but did not fix any of the concerns players had.
You can read about the Bounty Hunter System here on the [old] official forums.
This concept was discussed at a time where you used to lose 1% exp if you died in PvP. You could flag up and kill someone (-60k karma) and they would lose 1%, or they could kill you and you would lose 1% with no karma loss. This made everyone think twice about flagging up on someone and grind spots were very competitive, especially since the Mediah expansion was not released yet. I had many intense fights and I would only go back to contest if I knew I had messed up and could take them, or I would bring friends to help me win my spot back. However, the 1% exp loss was removed and PK became pointless. This was when Karma Bombing became acceptable.
My suggestions to fix the real issueThe issue is not with the amount of karma a person loses for PK, it is the fact that there is no reward and only harsh punishment. What is the point in killing someone if they can be back within 30 seconds? Why bother at all? The current system is completely unbalanced and allows griefing. It is going to take a lot of changes or a complete rework to fix. Here are some suggestions that I believe, would help to fix the issues once and for all.
- Remove Elion Tears from PvP – Elion Tears can be used to instantly resurrect back up. This isn’t much of an issue, unless you’re in the desert against a red player. You should not be able to pay to resurrect after a fight and then finish off the person who is still flagged, sending them straight to jail.
- Town only spawns – If you are killed in PvP you should only be able to resurrect at the closest town, this would stop players from being able to instantly come back, slowing down Karma Bombing and making it less effective.
- Chance of gem loss – bring back penalties for dying in open world PvP. Gem loss is not as severe as losing exp at the higher levels but would still make players think twice about coming back. If they do not have any gems they will lose EXP.
- Karma loss depends on opponents level – If a player is the same level as you they would lose less karma. This would stop players from being able to grief lower levels but would also be more fair when fighting for grinding spots.
- Multiple kills for less karma loss – Although it was only a rumor that this was implemented in Korea, if there was a timer that allowed you to kill the same person multiple times for less or no karma, then it would fix karma bombing.
- Remove death to PvE in PvP – You shouldn’t be able to die to monsters when engaged in PvP.
- You shouldn’t be able to deflag if you have been hit – The current flagging system allows you to flag up, hit someone then stop hitting them for a short amount of time and deflag. If the person is hit they should not be able to deflag as quickly.
- Buff Valencia – Sausans and Pirates are currently overcrowded due to lack of better spots. Valencia exp and money should be buffed to encourage players to move away from the lower level zones and keep sausans/pirates for people who are simply trying to level up.
- Nerf Sausan/Pirates exp and drops for level 56 or higher – Keep sausans/pirates as a lower level zone by reducing the amount of exp and drops you get past level 56. This would encourage higher level players to go find other places to grind and new players would not be forced to compete with higher levels for a grind spot.